I used to feel this way, but I decided to take a page from Oprah's Magazine, and purge the extra. Some shoes just hurt, and why the hell would I wear them anyway? To look cute? Screw that!! Here's my closet:
I kept a few dressy shoes, one pair especially. They do make my feet ache pretty good, but I just can't part with them. I do love my shoes. Old, odd, unusual, comfy, sometimes downright weird, but I love 'em. Maybe someday I'll show off the more unusual ones.